Murderously insane and likeable at the same time: Sweeney Todd, at the Kavinoky Theater

Sweeney Todd, the Demon Barber of Fleet Street. Music by Stephen Sondheim, book by Hugh Wheeler. At the Kavinoky Theater, directed by John Fredo.

The complicated Victorian-era story is about a man who was wrongly accused of a crime and sentenced to prison in Australia for fifteen years. On his return to London, he is told his beautiful daughter has become the ward (actually, concubine) of the evil judge who sentenced him, and that his wife has since poisoned herself. To wreak his revenge, he takes the name of Sweeney Todd, sets himself up as a barber above a meat pie shop and the friendly woman who helps him, and murders a slew of customers, ultimately murdering the judge himself.

I had never seen this musical before. I love Sondheim. This is of course a macabre, grotesque story, full of sometimes humorous songs that belie and are dissonant to the murderous events. That's Sondheim. If it's possible to enjoy a play where you like and feel moved by people who are insanely murderous, then this is that play. Todd is insane. Mrs. Lovett, who makes meat pies out of the corpses of Todd's victims, is insane. They cold-bloodedly murder people who have done them no harm. Yet, we like them, their songs are about love, affection, overcoming hardships. How can we not like them and feel moved by their complicated stories?

There is that central falsehood in this play. The lyricist can give Todd and Mrs. Lovett these songs. The playwright can put reasonable words in their mouths, and give them actions that show them to be compassionate, caring people. Yet they are monsters who cut the throats of innocents as well as evil judges. In what reality can such a story take place?

The cast and the entire production were great. Matt Witten's Todd was controlled and restrained. Todd is seething with rage, and yet we see a quiet, almost contemplative Todd on the stage (up until the instant he slits the throats of his victims). Witten's restraint, and the music, heightened the tension leading up to the two attempts on the judge's life -- almost unbearable, Sweeney Todd wielding the razor, we know what he's about to do, and he's singing. Anthony Lazzaro was exceptional as the young innocent sailor Anthony Hope (great name).